Day 2/ Night 2

[SuperJerry]

If we do get to find out their role that will be great with making a claim later on.

If I Janitor the hit tonight, do I also get to Reverse track if I get Roleblocked or anything?

[bill]

DeviousView

So do we janitor ghost who claimed Riddler so we can steal his claim?

Or

Target someone else and roll the dice? Just maybe we find out their role in the bargain and have a truly safe claim.

Keep in mind that ghosta will probably claim to have been silenced next day phase and put the heat on grin or strange.

[Jeff]

Oct 29, 2010 9:56:51 GMT -5 SuperJerry said:

If we do get to find out their role that will be great with making a claim later on.

If I Janitor the hit tonight, do I also get to Reverse track if I get Roleblocked or anything?

You other powers work normally, yes.

[bill]

Riddler has green pants so I'm trying to figure out if we could somehow steal the role for strange, with out it blowing up in our face.

[SuperJerry]

And I just want to note that because I'm Superman I did dress up as Clark Kent today at work.

[Grinner]

I don't know about janitoring Ghosta.

If he is Riddler and we use the claim, there's going to be a lot of, "Why didn't you say something then?" It's also going to look pretty coincidental that ghosta, who just happened to be the Riddler was janitored and now whomever is using the claim just happens to be the Riddler.

[stranger]

Oct 29, 2010 11:21:35 GMT -5 Grinner said:

I don't know about janitoring Ghosta.

If he is Riddler and we use the claim, there's going to be a lot of, "Why didn't you say something then?" It's also going to look pretty coincidental that ghosta, who just happened to be the Riddler was janitored and now whomever is using the claim just happens to be the Riddler.

Yes, but get_1 just happened to steal from someone with green pants, who happened to be silenced.

I find advantages and disadvantages with it.

[bill]

So what do you think about taking out ghosta, and not stealing his claim? I think that might be the safest course overall.

[bill]

The fact he will go with out a reveal would just be confusion gravy.

[stranger]

Ideally, we'd want to shut Ghosta up and at the same time kill someone with green pants.

Any ideas on how to achieve this?

[bill]

Lex wears green on occasion. If we could identify and kill him that would be a good claim, however that doesn't silence ghosta. I suppose if we knew the targets for the silencer and could misdirect him that would do the trick. A lot could go wrong with all of that though.

[SuperJerry]

If we knew the silencer that would help and I think we could maybe pull off a MD to keep Ghosta quiet. However, I think if he comes out and says he was silenced, it'll give us more problems and maybe end up with Stranger getting lynched. I'd say the safest bet is to Janitor kill Ghosta tonight. It'll keep the silence thing safe and not put more of a target on Strangers back.

So looking at something like this:

Superman - Janitor Kill Ghosta

Batman - Find out info on someone we have no clue about

Robin - Safe to probably have Chi target him

Aquaman - sit around and play Pokemon

Wonder Woman - Misdirect Rokk or Quebbs

[bill]

Oh Black Manta wore green pants and changed his name to Manta, even talks about it on Seanbaby's site. If get_1 is Manta and we take him out we might fake claim that.

[SuperJerry]

I thought Get_1 was Grundy?

[stranger]

Who knows with Get_1, he jumps around all the time.

I thought Wonder Woman was a bus driver, a double misdirector, which is why I first suggested switching Rokk and mine's places.
But since that's not the case I don't know how important Scarecrow really is to misdirect.

Personally, I think we should kill Ghosta and not use the janitored claim.